The Annual Report for 2001/2002 includes the following sections:
President's Report
Council
Branches Committee
Conferences Committee
Editorial Board
Professional Development Committee
Publications Committee
Publicity and Membership Committee
Teaching Committee
028 Mathematics
in Further, Tertiary and Continuing Education Subcommittee
064 A
and AS Level Mathematics Subcommittee
093 Teaching
and Learning Undergraduate Mathematics (TaLUM) Subcommittee
095 Scottish
Interests Subcommittee
114 Starting as a Secondary Mathematics
Teacher Subcommittee
116 Mathematics Books for the School
Library
118 ICT Subcommittee
119 Numeracy Across the Curriculum
Subcommittee
120 Managing a Mathematics Department
Subcommittee
121 Primary Subcommittee
122 Geometry 2002 Subcommittee
123 Spreadsheets 14 – 16 Subcommittee
124 Problem Pages 11 – 16
Subcommittee
125 BECTa Communicators Subcommittee
126 Monitoring Current Developments
Subcommittee
127 Mathematics Across the Curriculum
Subcommittee
129 Post-16 Subcommittee
Library Management Committee
Primary Maths Challenge
Problem Bureau
Headquarters
Rules and Regulations
Reports from representatives on other bodies
Accounts
PRESIDENT'S REPORT
Some time in 1978 or 1979, a teacher at a neighbouring school,
one Trish Morgan, asked me if I would like to go to a meeting about
teaching mathematics. Some 20+ years later, I find myself writing
a report at the end of my year as President of The Mathematical
Association. I have had three terrific jobs in that time, firstly
as mathematics co-ordinator at Severne Road Junior School, then
in the mathematics advisory team for the City of Birmingham and
latterly researching and teaching beginning primary school teachers
at the University of Wales, Swansea. I have gained an M.Ed and a
PhD along the way. I have also visited Canada, Portugal, Spain,
Brazil, Australia and Japan to discuss teaching mathematics. And
all because I went to a meeting with Trish Morgan. Thanks, Trish!
I was surprised and honoured to be asked to be President and although
I had decided to take a break after periods as Chair of Teaching
Committee and Chair of Council, how could I refuse? Very few Presidents,
other than Hilary Shuard, have a primary background and I think
I may well be the first who was working in Wales.
Strangely enough, for someone who had worked on Council for a number
of years, I was not completely sure what I would be expected to
do as President. As those of you who have attended previous AGMs
will recall, there are extensive rules and regulations governing
the running of the Association but there does not appear to be a
'President's Handbook'. Indeed, the new President, Barry Lewis,
and I have started to draft such a tome.
What did I expect?
Well, I knew I would have to give a Presidential Address at the
end of the year. This seemed rather strange, as one might expect
an Address to set the agenda for the Presidential Year. Luckily,
I regularly lecture to large groups as part of my job so I was not
too fazed by this expectation, although I did want to make sure
that my address would have something for everyone, whether they
were working in a primary school, a secondary school, FE or HEI.
I was standing on Bristol Parkway Station on my way back from a
Council Meeting when I spotted a brilliant poster advertisement
for Joanne Harris' book 'Five quarters of the orange' and
an idea came to me - we don't just form our ideas about mathematics
from our classroom interactions but from all around us. I had the
basis for my Address.
I rather expected to be inundated with invitations from Branches
but this did not happen! I did receive the traditional invitation
to the President from the Cardiff Branch. For this President, that
was very convenient! I was able to try out a multi-media approach
and some of the ideas for my Presidential Address. I had been invited
to the London Primary Conference, but unfortunately this event had
to be cancelled.
I was also invited to some wonderful events, although it was not
always clear whether I was being invited as President of The Mathematical
Association or because of my work with other organisations. However,
I always took the opportunity to promote the MA and passed a number
of contacts and ideas on to Council. One in particular I would like
to see us develop, is the nomination of someone for a Teaching Award
(more information at http://www.teachingawards.com/). I did write
and congratulate the two area winners who were mathematics teachers
and invited them to our Conference, but neither were able to attend.
I hope it will become a tradition to invite such winners.
Another opportunity that came our way that I would like to see
as a regular feature, was the possibility to sponsor a member who
is going to work for VSO for a year. Look out for articles in our
periodicals from Frieda Wilkinson on her time in The Gambia.
Perhaps one element of being President of which I was a little
unsure, was answering questions from the Press. I had a great deal
of support from members of Council and other contacts within the
Association, who very speedily responded to my requests for information
and advice prior to 'giving an interview'. In particular, Teaching
Committee was able to provide valuable and well-informed views from
the membership, which gave me confidence. In the main, both the
articles written by journalists and the pieces I had published in
the Times Educational Supplement were well received. I don't
think the Chair of Council had to apologise on my behalf too many
times!
What did I want to achieve?
As all good teachers know, we must have intended outcomes for our
endeavours. What did I hope to achieve as President of The Association?
On reflection, I had three main objectives and I believe I made
some progress on one of these at least.
Firstly, I am committed to the right of every learner to be taught
by a competent, confident and enthusiastic teacher of mathematics;
hence the title for the Conference 'The very best mathematics
for all'. The Mathematical Association has been at the forefront
of lobbying politicians and advising policy makers for a very long
time and, in recent years, we have seen some inroads into this ongoing
challenge. This issue is being followed up on many fronts and was
the theme of both the articles I wrote for TES. I am continuing
to be very active on this in all aspects of my work.
Secondly, I wanted to demonstrate to teachers in the primary phase
that the Association had much to offer them. I think if I could
have visited Branches and given a talk with a primary theme, this
may have been productive but the opportunities did not arise. Perhaps
I should have been more pro-active, so here goes. Many Branches
have a VIth Form event, why not have a primary event? After the
national tests, I'm sure many schools are looking for alternative
and exciting activities for their Year 6 pupils. Given the appropriate
date, I could bring some PGCE students along to help run the day.
Why not ask the Immediate Past President to do something for your
Branch next summer? We also invited a significant number of primary
teachers to contribute to the Annual Conference and those who were
able to accept gave sessions that were much appreciated. However,
we must ensure that our publicity for the next Conference has a
clear indication of the primary offerings as well as those for secondary.
Thirdly, I have always been an advocate of collaboration between
the many and varied societies that work in the area of mathematics
education. There are some examples of good practice; our previous
joint conferences with ATM, the meetings of representatives from
a range of societies with QCA and of course the activities of the
Joint Mathematical Council for which I act as Honorary Secretary.
I am very pleased that this year has seen the beginning of an independent
committee (Advisory Committee on Mathematics Education), which acts
as a single voice for the mathematical community and is supported
by The Royal Society and Joint Mathematical Council, and funded
by The Gatsby Foundation.
In Conclusion:
I would like to thank The Association for the honour and opportunities
afforded by my year as President. I wish the new President, Barry
Lewis, every success. May the Association go from strength to strength
and I wish all the members every success for themselves and their
pupils.
Sue Sanders (President)
COUNCIL
As normal, Council has had four meetings since the last AGM. Meetings
were held early in June, September, December and March. In addition,
Standing Committee met three times. The Council meetings have been
well attended and a great deal of business is accomplished. Inevitably,
there is some tension between allowing thorough discussion and getting
through the business in a reasonable time. The extent to which this
was managed is for others to judge rather than the Chair. I should,
on behalf of the Association, as well as for myself, publicly express
appreciation to the members of Council for the time they give up
to attend meetings. It should be remembered that, in most cases,
members will also be participating in other meetings or staffing
stalls at exhibitions or generally be working to promote our Association
in the mathematical community.
It seems to me that the Association is in a period of great change.
I reported last year that we had bought in the services of John
Day, a professional marketer. For most of the year, John worked
on our behalf for one day a week. This allowed him to initiate a
membership drive. However, once things are moving, it requires less
effort to keep them going so, for the last few months, John's input
has been on the basis of half a day per week. John has tried a number
of ways to increase the membership. All could realistically be described
as experimental and some were by no means as successful as others.
However, it is very clear that the project has been successful with
a substantial increase of membership being recorded. It does need
to be pointed out that virtually all this growth has been in increasing
the number of institutional members. In practical terms, it is possible
to direct mailings to schools but it is not quite clear how to do
the same for individuals. So, in that sense, the membership profile
is changing. Up to now, the focus has been on larger schools but
we have recently mailed all secondary schools with very encouraging
results and all primary schools are to be mailed during the summer
term.
Mention of primary schools brings me nicely to The Primary Mathematics
Challenge. This initiative has now completed a trial year and two
full years. It is proving to be very successful, both in providing
challenging material for primary teachers to use and generating
income. In the letter to primary schools referred to above, we are
wanting schools to join but we are also pushing PMC very hard. I
should like to pay tribute to the committee who run the PMC. Peter
Bailey is its leader and the other members are: Ruth Cullingworth,
Robyn Pickles, Colin Abell and Trish Morgan. I must also acknowledge
the contribution of Tony Gardiner whose idea it was some years ago.
This is another project, which, without his drive and enthusiasm,
would not have happened. Who knows, in years to come, the MA may
be considered as an offshoot of the PMC!
Last year, I also highlighted Continuing Professional Development
for the progress that was being made. I am pleased to say that this
area continues to progress. The 'old' projects are still ongoing,
but we have also begun what we hope will be a long lasting series
for one-day events to assist teachers with their obligations for
the Gifted and Talented. So far, two such events have taken place,
the first in Didcot and a second in Leeds. Both were full, so it
would appear that there is a strong demand for such activities.
We feel that the CPD activities are going so well that we need more
assistance. To that end, we advertised a part-time post, which will
include some CPD activities. The response to the advertisement has
been very good and we plan to resolve the situation before the end
of April.
Our headquarters staff continue to work hard for the Association.
There have been changes in a number of aspects since the last AGM.
Graham Richards left at the end of November to pursue his vocation
in the Church. Graham deserves our thanks for taking on added responsibility
during the time of Heather Whitby's illness. Many of you will have
met his replacement, Lisa Hall, at the Annual Conference. At my
age, nearly everybody looks young but Lisa looks very young indeed.
As many will remember, Graham worked in a part-time capacity; it
is very pleasing that Lisa is full-time. The other members of staff
continue under the expert guidance of Marcia, our indispensable
Office Manager. The building itself has not been neglected. There
has been a substantial programme of redecoration and a new computer
system has been installed. We are making progress but there is still
much to do!
Finally, I have the sad and happy task of reporting the comings
and goings of council members. At this stage, Council bids farewell
to Robyn Pickles after three years, Steve Abbot also after three
years, and Trish Morgan after lots of years. In her time on Council,
Robyn helped guide decisions relating to the primary school sector;
I am pleased that she is to continue her involvement in the PMC.
Steve leaves us after three 'presidential' years; in his time on
Council he has made a major contribution to the Association and
I am convinced that we would not be as strongly placed without his
efforts and vision. I should also like to place on record our thanks
to him for the seven years he spent as editor of the Mathematical
Gazette. Now, what can be said about Trish Morgan? She was on Council
in the early 1990s when I first joined; she had a short break, but
couldn't keep away and rejoined in about 1996. She was an excellent
member of Council; she had lots of good ideas but was always willing
to take on board the views of others. In recent years, she occupied
the role as the member-without-office on Standing Committee and
she made sure the Officers behaved. In addition, for the last year,
she has been the member responsible for Headquarters. As with Robyn,
Trish has been in the PMC team and is willing to continue. There
is one change of position. Paul Metcalf has been our treasurer since
1997. He brought to that job a professionalism that it had not previously
received. I cannot but applaud the stylish way in which he has educated
Council in financial matters and done much to improve our lot. Amazingly,
after five years of really hard work, he is still keen to continue
on Council and has accepted the post of Chair of the Publications.
We need to thank him for what he has done for us, as well as for
what he is going to do. In a sense, there is another change as Michael
Fox has been a co-opted member and is taking over the Treasurer's
role from Paul. I am pleased to welcome three fresh members-without-office.
They are Ruth Cullingworth, a primary school teacher in Gloucester,
Nick Lord, a secondary school teacher from Tonbridge, and Keith
Cadman, who has an advisory type of role in the West Midlands.
Bill Richardson (Chair of Council)
BRANCHES COMMITTEE
The Branches committee held two meetings during the last year,
the first in April 2001 and the second in November 2001. Both meetings
were held at the Leicester Headquarters of the Association. During
the year, Linda Moon resigned as Secretary of the Branches Committee
and I would like to thank Linda for all of her hard work during
her period in office. Dave Pountney has taken over from Linda as
the Secretary of the Branches Committee.
The Branches perform an important role within the Association,
as they can organise a range of activities for local members including
talks on topics of interest, problem evenings for school pupils
and discussion sessions for teachers. Whilst most Branches do organise
a highly successful programme of activities, some Branches are in
decline due to the fall in local membership. Therefore I would like
to take this opportunity to urge all members who are in the catchment
area for one of the Branches to join that Branch and get involved
in the activities of the Branch. Contact details for each Branch
are regularly published in MA News and can be found on the Association's
web site.
During the year, two Branches, Thames Valley and Manchester, closed.
A new Branch is being created in Northern Ireland. As chairman of
the Branches Committee, I can help and advise any group of members
who would like to start a new Branch, and the Council of the Association
can provide financial help with the costs of starting up a new Branch.
Paul Harris (Chair of Branches Committee)
CONFERENCES COMMITTEE
In 2001 the Annual Conference was held at the St. Martin's College,
Lancaster from the 8th to 11th April. Over 180 delegates attended
for all or part of the conference.
The theme of the conference was 'Visualising Mathematics'. In all,
a total of 68 presentations were offered organised into 9 sessions
over the four days of the conference. Together with the magnificent
publishers' exhibition there was a plethora of exciting activities.
A quiz, ceilidh and an entertaining lecture from Sarah Flannery
on 'Exploring and Discovering Maths Through Puzzles' were held in
the evenings, together with formal receptions and the annual dinner
with after-dinner speaker Simon Singh.
The opening lecture was delivered by Celia Hoyles, who spoke on
'Developing A Mathematical Habit Of Mind'; the Hilary Shuard Memorial
Lecture was given by Mike Askew about developments in teaching primary
mathematics and Barry Lewis admirably closed the conference with
his presentation on 'Perception in Maths - The Calculus of Change'.
The Presidential Address, 'Rank and File; Vision and Visualisations',
was given by Steve Abbott; a splendid powerpoint presentation. All
of these sessions were well attended, stimulating and entertaining.
In 2002 the Annual Conference was held at the Reading University
from the 3rd to 6th April. Over 160 delegates attended for all or
part of the conference.
The theme of the conference was 'The Very Best Mathematics For
All'. In all, a total of 67 presentations were offered, organised
into 10 sessions over the four days of the conference. Together
with the magnificent publishers' exhibition, there was again a plethora
of exciting activities. A quiz and an entertaining icebreakers session
from Brian Bolt were held in the evenings, together with formal
receptions and the annual dinner with after-dinner speaker Ray Monk.
The opening lecture was delivered by Brian Butterworth who spoke
on 'Mathematics and The Brain', the Hilary Shuard Memorial Lecture
was given by Tim Coulson on the conference theme of 'The Very Best
Mathematics for All' and was complemented by a very entertaining
ICT Plenary session from Douglas Butler entitled 'But We Managed
with a Piece of Chalk for Centuries' and Derek Holton closed the
conference in his own inimitable style with his interactive presentation
on 'Maths Is Dead. Long Live Grapejuice'. Sue Sanders gave the Presidential
Address, 'Tales from the mathematical classroom', which was an excellent
multi-media extravaganza. All of these sessions were well attended,
stimulating and entertaining.
Both of these conferences were a great success thanks to all the
hard work put in by the organising team both before and during these
events. The Annual Conference is an ideal place to share ideas,
meet and make friends, and recharge your mathematical batteries.
It is certainly excellent value for money and I would encourage
all members of the Association to come to the conference soon, and
better still, bring a friend! You'll go back after the Easter break
feeling refreshed, better informed and more enthusiastic.
We look forward to seeing you at future conferences, the next one
is The University of East Anglia, Norwich from the 12th to 15th
April 2003.
Martin Bailey (Chair of Conferences Committee)
EDITORIAL BOARD
As always my first task has to be to thank, on behalf of the membership,
all of the Editors and Assistant Editors for their dedication and
hard work over the year, and all the other people involved in production,
advertising, reviews, proof-reading, creating puzzles and problems,
writing articles, designing covers, creating web pages etc., etc.
There have been some problems and some changes over the year.
Firstly, please do accept my sincere apologies - as well as those
of the editor, for the late arrivals of SymmetryPlus this
year. We will try to be more punctual. (There have been some problems
involving lost proofs, the Royal Mail and a computer that crashed.
The problem is if you do miss the deadline, you miss the mail shot
altogether and so have to wait to hitch a ride on the next Maths
in Schools issue.)
Secondly, we have had to say farewell to Steve Abbott (Editor of
The Mathematical Gazette) and Malcolm Sanders (Editor of
Primary Mathematics). I cannot express my thanks adequately
for all the hard work that they have done. You are both wonderful!
Each of these very successful editors has made such a huge mark
on the journal they were editing. You are both going to be VERY
hard acts to follow. I think the only thing remaining is to say
a big THANK YOU to you both.
So now you will have realised that the third thing I need to say
is that we have two new editors. Gerry Leversha has taken over as
editor of the Gazette and Lynne McClure has taken over as
editor of Primary Maths. I am sure that the membership will
join me in wishing them success.
For those unaware of the journals we produce (shame on you!) I
reprint this novice's guide I wrote last year.
'The Mathematical Gazette' (3 issues per year) and 'Mathematics
in Schools' (5 issues per year) continue to be high quality,
popular and well-respected journals and a pleasure to read.
'Mathematical Pie' (3 issues per year) continues to publish
creative, fresh and entertaining puzzles and thought-provoking items.
'Equals' (3 issues per year) and 'Primary Mathematics'
(3 issues per year), each seem to be going from strength to strength.
'SymmetryPlus' (3 issues per year) continues to be a good
read with lots of useful ideas, articles and puzzles for both teachers
and pupils.
The 'MA News' is informative, entertaining, humorous and
topical, what more could one ask for in a newsletter!
Our web site is increasingly popular, topical and, by its very
nature, developing, refining and extending itself.
As you can see from the list above, the MA has many journals and
covers a very broad spectrum of readership tastes, publishing between
them a very broad spectrum of items. The Editors are always in need
of copy in the form of articles, puzzles, notes, games, pictures
etc. So.......... Why not make 2002/2003 the year you (or
one of your students?) submit your first item to one of these journals!
Come on, be brave!!!!.
Susie Jameson (Editor in Chief)
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
The Professional Development Committee has spent a substantial
amount of time in the past year keeping up with developments and
raising issues related to the training and professional development
of mathematics teachers.
Meetings have been held with the DfEE, Key Stage 3 Strategy Directors,
General Teaching Council and the Teacher Training Agency. Some of
these have been convened on behalf of a smaller group of subject
associations (ASE, DATA, GA, HA, NATE, MA). Attending these meetings
has been a key part of the role for both the Committee Chair and
the Professional Development Officer of the Association.
The MA was awarded funds in summer 2000 to run award-bearing INSET.
We have continued to run courses with the University of Exeter with
these funds and more than 20 teachers are currently studying for
an award.
T3 courses have been offered in a variety of locations this year,
with more than 900 teachers attending training in 2001. Further
courses are planned for later this year. Following the publication
of the Key Stage 3 Framework for Mathematics in April 2001, there
has been an increase in interest in this technology and we have
worked with a number of Local Education Authorities, and trained
Key Stage Three consultants as a result. Training has also been
offered to Initial Teacher Training students through T3.
In total, more than 90 teachers have attended one-day courses offered
by The Mathematical Association on working with able pupils in mathematics.
These courses were over-subscribed and we are hoping to run them
again in the future. Our thanks go to Tony Gardiner, Jennie Golding
and Tony Burgall for making these events so successful.
Adrian Oldknow (Chair of Professional Development
Committee)
Ros Hyde (Professional Development Officer)
PUBLICATIONS COMMITTEE
At the start of year Peter Bailey relinquished his role as Chair
of Publications Committee and Bill Brakes took on the role of acting
chair. Recently Paul Metcalf has been elected Chair.
The most significant decision of the year was to put the Geometry
book, celebrating 100 years of Publications Committee, to an outside
publisher. In view of the significance of this book, either decision
- to publish in-house, or to use a professional publisher - carried
an element of risk. The effect of this decision will be monitored
so as to inform future decisions.
Two new publications this year were Starting Out as a Secondary
Mathematics Teacher and Dictionary of Mechanics. In addition
many established publications continued to sell well, with a number
of reprints undertaken. The Primary Mathematics Challenge continues
to go from strength to strength, with further expansion this year,
and generating a significant number of new members for the MA. In
addition a PMC Book - including questions from previous years, solutions
and hints - was prepared in time for Conference 2002.
During the year, the following members have served on the Publications
Committee: Bill Brakes, Cathleen Brunt, Ian Evans, David Hodgson,
Paul Metcalf, Colin Abell, Sue Waring. Bill Richardson, Peter Bailey,
and John Day have also attended. Lisa Hall is the member of staff
who now serves the Committee.
If any member has an ambition to be involved in publishing, enjoys
decision-making and would like to be a part of this Committee, then
please contact Paul Metcalf on 0116 221 0013.
Bill Brakes (Acting Chair of Publications Committee)
PUBLICITY AND MEMBERSHIP COMMITTEE
The Association was represented at BETT and The Education Show.
We were very pleased with the response from teachers at these events.
We also attended various smaller events, with the MEI Conference
being particularly successful.
What can you as members do?
- In Primary Schools - subscribe to EQUALS - use materials
from Primary Mathematics with your pupils - enter the PMC
and buy Primary Mathematics Challenge 1999/2002, the new
PMC book.
- In Secondary Schools - encourage your feeder primaries to enter
the PMC - use Mathematics in School in your lessons.
- If you have contact with students in teacher training - use
MA materials so that they see them and are attracted to use them.
- All members - encourage others to join by
showing how useful our periodicals and publications really are.
David Hodgson (Chair of Publicity amd Membership
Committee)
TEACHING COMMITTEE
Teaching Committee was founded in 1902, so 2002 is our centenary
year. We are celebrating by producing a book: Simplicity, Economy
and Elegance. It is a collection of readings on geometry taken from
the Association's publications over the last hundred years, including
items by G.H. Hardy and Bertrand Russell as well as more recent
contributors. The book also includes a variety of Desert Island
Theorems contributed by a wide range of distinguished mathematicians
and educators. The editor is Chris Pritchard who has devoted a vast
amount of time and energy to the project for which we are immensely
grateful. Our thanks also go to Bill Richardson who is doing the
typesetting. We hope that the book will be a distinctive contribution
to mathematical literature and that it will reach a wide audience
across the world.
The role of Teaching Committee is 'to keep under review matters
concerning the teaching and learning of mathematics and to address
matters of potential future importance'. We put this into practice
in two distinct ways:
- Providing advice and resources for teachers of mathematics;
- Seeking to influence national policies on mathematics education.
Teaching Committee consists of a chair, secretary, treasurer, up
to eight elected members and several ex-officio members. The current
membership is listed at the end of Teaching Committee News.
I should like to record my thanks to Colin Abell, Roy Ashley, Linda
Moon and Richard Wilson who have each served Teaching Committee
well in different ways over many years and who have left us during
the year. We are very pleased to welcome Robert Barbour, Anna Dunlop,
Mary Ledwick, Ray Steele and Geoff Tennant who have joined us this
year.
I should also like to record our very considerable thanks to Peter
Thomas whose term of office as secretary comes to an end in June.
Peter has been a superbly efficient and effective secretary, a role
which he combines with so many other valued contributions both to
the Association and in other ways to mathematical education. He
will be a hard act to follow, but we are immensely grateful to Geoff
Tennant for agreeing to take on the role of secretary as Peter's
successor.
I should also like to thank all the other members of the Committee
for their help and support during the year, and to all the chairs
and members of subcommittees for all the good work that they continue
to do. Everybody who contributes to the work of Teaching Committee
is a volunteer, who gives up their precious free time to further the
work of the Association, whilst doing a full time job in some sector
of the education system. Like everybody else in education we all have
too much to do and too little time in which to do it, so I can only
express my admiration and gratitude that so many are prepared to give
so generously of their time and energies.
Teaching Committee represents the wide range of mathematical interests
to be found amongst the members of the Association. We have a wide
geographical spread – from Exeter to Elgin – and we have a variety
of members from primary, secondary, tertiary and higher education.
The Committee meets three times a year in York and holds an Open
Meeting each year at Conference. We are always on the lookout for
new ideas and members who are willing to develop them.
Besides the geometry book, two other books will be published over
the next year: Leading and Managing Mathematics: a Handbook for
the Head of Mathematics, which is being produced by a subcommittee
chaired by Will Connolly, and Problem Pages 11 to 16, a new
collection of problems for the 11 to 16 age range being compiled
by Barbara Cullingworth and Steve Drape. In addition, work is proceeding
on other publications for 2003 and beyond, on spreadsheets for the
14 to 16 age range, mathematics across the curriculum and A-level
mathematics.
Most of Teaching Committee's work is done by its subcommittees.
These have a variety of roles and take many different forms. A typical
one may have about six members, meet once a term on a Saturday and
aim to produce a publication over a period of two or three years.
Other subcommittees consist of only one or two people or conduct
their business by e-mail and may have more of a focus on influencing
policies and responding to events. People invariably find that working
as a member of a subcommittee is a stimulating and rewarding experience,
so do consider offering to contribute in some way. Details of the
rich variety of activity appear in the rest of this issue of Teaching
Committee. Do come along to the Open Meeting at Conference to find
out more and do write to us with your thoughts and contributions.
Doug French
(Chair of Teaching Committee)
Teaching Committee
Membership March 2002 Officers
| Chair |
Doug French |
University of
Hull |
| Vice-Chair |
Charlie Stripp |
MEI and Exeter
College, Exeter |
| Secretary |
Peter Thomas |
Hills Road Sixth Form
College, Cambridge |
| Treasurer |
Janet Jagger |
Leeds |
| Elected
Members |
Ex-Officio
Members |
| Cathleen Brunt |
St John Fisher
School, Harrogate |
Robert Barbour |
Secretary of The
Association |
| Jane Imrie |
Newark |
Anna Dunlop |
Representative of
Branches Committee |
| Mary Ledwick |
Clitheroe |
David Hodgson |
Chair of Publicity
and Membership Committee |
| Chris Pritchard |
McLaren High School,
Callander |
Susie Jameson |
Editor-in-Chief |
| Ray Steele |
Trinity and All
Saints College, Leeds |
Marcia Murray |
chief executive of
The Association |
| Geoff Tennant |
University of
Leicester |
|
| Others members during 2001
| Elected
Members |
Ex-Officio
Members |
| Colin Abell |
St Edward's CE(A)
Middle School, Leek |
Roy Ashley |
Secretary of The
Association |
| Richard Wilson |
Mark Rutherford
School, Bedford |
Linda Moon |
Representative of
Branches Committee |
Reports from
Subcommittees
93 Teaching and Learning Undergraduate Mathematics
(TaLUM) Subcommittee
TALUM works through two main subgroups: 'Content'
and 'Learning and Assessment'.
The 'Content' subgroup had looked at the question
of language and whether students understood words and phrases in the way
lecturers did. The group has focused on quantifiers and negation and are
devising two tests on this topic, one to be given to students on entry to
their undergraduate course and the other after the students have had
lectures, etc. on this topic during their first semester. These tests are
currently being given and the analysis should follow soon.
The 'Learning and Assessment' subgroup is
following up on the work published in Mathematics
Teaching about PGCE students' attitudes to their mathematics degrees
by repeating their survey on a larger scale and including third year
undergraduates who are not going on to teach. In addition, TALUM maintains
links with 'MidMath' which is looking at the secondary/tertiary interface
and, through links with the Post-16 Subcommittee has conducted a survey
into the uptake of Further Mathematics A and AS levels in the light of
recent changes to pre-university teaching.
TALUM gratefully acknowledges the financial
support it receives from the MA, LMS and ATM and looks forward to
continuing its work this year.
Adrian Simpson
(Chair)
118 ICT Subcommittee
The subcommittee is a standing group which
circulates material by e-mail when required. This year it looked as if our
main task would be to prepare a set of materials for the DfES to accompany
the laptops ordered by KS3 mathematics teachers under their Computers for
Teachers Phase 3 scheme. In the event, though, that idea foundered on the
issues of cost and administration. However the DfES have now asked the
British Educational and Communications Technology Agency (BECTa) to
produce guidance materials in ICT for all secondary school subject
departments, and Adrian Oldknow has been asked to edit the mathematics
materials, which will bear the MA logo alongside the BECTa and DfES ones.
Work on this will get underway in 2002 in association with the KS3
mathematics strategy.
As many will know, the KS3 mathematics strategy
has been the major focus of professional development activities in
secondary school mathematics this year. So far it is not given any
attention to ICT in the training materials developed from the Framework.
However 2002 is set to see the "great leap forward" in terms of ICT use in
secondary schools as the KS3 strategy turns its attention towards this
aspect of enhancing mathematics teaching. Ros Hyde and Adrian Oldknow are
in regular (termly) contact with the KS3 strategy directors about issues
concerning professional development, and other members of TC, including
Doug French, are in contact with Carole McIntyre about the mathematics
strategy in particular.
Related to this, Ros Hyde and Adrian Oldknow are
receiving numbers of request from LEA consultants and advisers for ICT
& mathematics sessions under the T-cubed banner. Similary Neil
Challis, Ros Hyde and Adrian Oldknow have established close links with the
National Association for Numeracy and Mathematics in Colleges (NANAMIC)
and will be helping to run a series of four regional workshops in March
(Stafford, Kingston, York and Taunton). The TTA are clearly concerned that
the impact of the NOF-funded ICT training for secondary subject
specialists has not been as good as hoped for, and the MA is in discussion
with TTA for proposals to improve the situation with respect to some
providers.
Finally it is a pleasure to report that BECTa is
also making great leaps forward both in being proactive in commissioning
new mathematics materials and in taking the lead in bringing about greater
co-operation between the various agencies such as the KS3 strategy, QCA
and TTA. Richard Bridges, Ros Hyde and Adrian Oldknow are all members of
the BECTa mathematics consultative group which looks like having a much
greater role to play in the near future.
Adrian Oldknow
(Chair)
120 Managing a Mathematics Department
Subcommittee
The subcommittee has continued its work on
producing the handbook, Leading and Managing
Mathematics: a Handbook for the Head of Mathematics. It is hoped that
it will be published during 2002.
Will Connolly
(Chair)
121 Primary Subcommittee
The subcommittee continues to provide a voice for
members in the primary sector through its contribution to the
Association's twice-yearly meetings with QCA.
Robyn Pickles
(Chair)
122 Geometry 2002 Subcommittee
This subcommittee of one, aided by Doug French and
Jan Jagger is working towards the production of the proposed book, Simplicity, Economy and Elegance: Readings in
Geometry and Geometry Teaching. In recent weeks a decision has been
made to involve a publishing house in this venture and at the time of
writing (end-December 2001) negotiations are proceeding. As editor I have
been eliciting and editing contributions of two kinds to supplement the
archival material already identified for inclusion.
Of the five chapter introductions work is underway
on four. The general introduction is to be written last. Douglas
Hofstadter has agreed to write the foreword. There are to be 31 Desert
Island Theorems from leading mathematicians, educationalists and teachers
with close connections with The Mathematical Association. Some 23 theorems
have been submitted, including the selections of Coxeter, Atiyah, Devlin
and Singh. It is expected that the book will be published during 2002 to
celebrate the centenary of Teaching Committee.
There is sufficient material for a second volume
and the willingness of eminent mathematicians to contribute is such as to
suggest that in four or five years time the whole exercise could be
repeated should it prove successful.
Chris
Pritchard (Chair)
123 Spreadsheets 14 – 16 Subcommittee
The subcommittee held its first meeting in January
2002, following the appointment of the chair in late 2001. It has set
itself the task of producing a resource for comprehensive school teachers
which it is hoped will be ready in time for the Annual Conference in 2003.
The intention is to have five chapters: Introduction to Excel for
mathematics teaching, Excel as a teacher resource, Excel for pupil
explorations, Task-related Excel activities, Extended/advanced Excel
activities. Any member who wishes to participate would be welcome.
Denis Almeida
(Chair)
124 Problem Pages 11 – 16 Subcommittee
The aim of the subcommittee is to produce a book
of a similar format to Problem Pages but aimed at students who are aged 11
– 16. The current situation is that there are around forty problems in a
draft word-processed format. At the last meeting, on 10th December, it was
felt that more Handling Data problems were needed. The majority of the
present problems are numerical in nature and so a better balance needs to
be achieved. A further twenty-five problems were discussed and these
should be typed up and edited early in 2002.
The plan is to aim for a draft copy by the middle
of 2002. The focus of the next meeting will be to decide whether any of
the problems are to be rejected. The subcommittee would welcome any
further problems, which can be sent to the chair.
Steve Drape
(Chair)
125 BECTa Communicators Subcommittee
I am maintaining a watch on the BECTa web site. My
impression is that the mathematics discussion area is one of the best used
on the site, mainly because of the support of the ATM, and postings from
David Wright of BECTa. However, it is not nearly as well used as it could
be (with approximately 200 messages in 2 years, a few of which are very
recent). The original intention of BECTa was to try to channel all
mathematics discussion to the site. This would make it a very powerful
tool for gathering professional opinion, as well as for sharing practice.
There could be many reasons why it is not fulfilling its role. I suspect
accessibility might be one: we are still not yet in the fortunate position
that all teachers have access to the Internet at times to suit them. It is
also possible that a number of teachers are still unaware of it.
It would be helpful to know of any members of the
MA who use the site regularly. Equally useful would be the opinion of
those who know of the site, or have visited it, but who don't use it.
Further, if you are interested in helping to stimulate discussion on the
site, please let me know.
Jane Imrie
(Chair)
127 Mathematics
Across the Curriculum Subcommittee
The subcommittee is preparing a publication which
will raise awareness of mathematics in other subjects and give details of
resources available. It is hoped that that contacts can be made with other
subject associations.
Cathleen Brunt
(Chair)
129 Post-16 Subcommittee
This subcommittee has been formed by the merger of
the A/AS and FE subcommittees (subcommittees 64 and 28). The FE
subcommittee had been relatively inactive for some time, although the very
successful FE Forum at the 2001 Annual Conference led to the formation of
this new subcommittee.
A report into the current situation for A/AS level
Further Mathematics in schools and colleges was commissioned by the A/AS
subcommittee in 2001. This is now complete, but its significance has been
rather overtaken by the Curriculum 2000 disaster in AS Mathematics. The
conclusions of the report were that student numbers were relatively stable
into academic year 2000/2001, but there seems to have been an increase in
numbers in large sixth forms and colleges, with a corresponding decrease
in small sixth forms. It would have probably been better to have done the
research a year later, so that the effects of the Curriculum 2000 issue
could be evaluated.
The new subcommittee has met twice so far. There
is much enthusiasm in the new group and exciting new projects have already
been started. The subcommittee has been active in helping to frame the
MA's response to the Curriculum 2000 issue. Work in progress includes:
- Posters for the A level Mathematics classroom
- A book on 'Applications of Mathematics'. This
will be aimed at A-level Mathematics teachers and accessible to A-level
students. It will use real examples from industry.
A future project will be a publication to address
the mathematical misconceptions which often inhibit learning in A level
Mathematics students.
Members of the subcommittee are organising several
sessions on various post-16 issues for the 2002 Annual Conference.
Charlie Stripp
(Chair)
Other subcommittees during
2001
The subcommittees below have now concluded their
work.
028 Mathematics in Further, Tertiary and
Continuing Education This
subcommittee has merged with Subcommittee 64 to form Subcommittee 129. 064 A and AS Level Mathematics This
subcommittee has merged with Subcommittee 28 to form Subcommittee 129. 095 Scottish Interests 114 Starting as a Secondary Mathematics Teacher
The
subcommittee produced a new edition of Starting as
a Secondary Mathematics Teacher which was published during 2001. Linda
Moon (Chair) and other members of the subcommittee are thanked for their
work in producing a completely fresh version of this book. 116 Mathematics Books for the School Library
119 Numeracy Across the Curriculum The
subcommittee produced the handbook Numeracy Across
the Curriculum which was published during 2001. Cathleen Brunt (Chair)
and Mary Ledwick who formed this subcommittee are thanked for their work
in producing this book.
LIBRARY MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE
The Committee met on four occasions under the
chairmanship of Mike Price, with Marcia Murray as secretary and either
Stephen Rawlinson or David Welding representing the Library of the
University of Leicester, which accommodates all the Association's books
and periodicals.
The sorting of the large 1990s backlog of
acquisitions should be completed by the end of the summer term 2002.
Checking for duplicates has been a slow, painstaking process involving
both the card and electronic catalogues, and the catalogued books on the
shelves. Much of the work has been undertaken by Mary Walmsley, with
support from Mike Price and Howard Fay.
Duplicates are now being transferred in boxes to
the Association's headquarters, where they are being offered in the first
instance to members involved in Council or committee work. Offers of
further donations to the Library can now be welcomed and will be
investigated for their potential to enhance the collection.
The whole of the Special Collection of around 600
rarer books is being electronically catalogued as part of an externally
funded University project, which should be completed in 2002. Links to the
Association's website can then be developed. The backlog of 'new'
acquisitions is being electronically catalogued in small batches by
Library staff but some additional funding may be required to complete this
work in 2002. The bulk of the MA collection is still only card catalogued
and major funding in excess of £20,000 is being sought to transfer all the
records to the electronic database.
A new Service Level Agreement between the
Association and the University of Leicester has been negotiated and a
final version was jointly signed by Timothy Hobbs, University of Leicester
Librarian, and Bill Richardson, Chair of Council, on 18 January 2002. The
Agreement specifies the arrangements for collection management, liaison,
insurance, access and borrowing, including charges to members for postal
loans. Members' well-defined entitlements can now be generally
advertised.
The Association's collection is covered for
insurance purposes by the Library's general policy, which does not include
additional cover for the Special Collection, including the Wittgenstein
material (see below). The possibility of additional insurance has been
raised and a view from Council is awaited. Eleven Council members were
given a personal introduction to the Association's Library by Mike Price
at the University on Saturday 9 June 2001, with voluntary support from the
Stack Services Librarian, Linda Huig.
The significance and future of the Wittgenstein
material are still being investigated. Efforts to locate members of the
Goodstein family have proved unsuccessful. An initial opinion was provided
by Ian Smith of Bernard Quaritch Ltd., and a second opinion on the
material is being obtained from staff at Trinity College, Cambridge, to
which the material has been temporarily transferred (with additional
insurance in transit). Ray Monk, a biographer of Wittgenstein, has also
expressed an interest in evaluating the material back in Leicester. The
possibility of extended loan, e.g. to Trinity College, and some resulting
income for the Association have still to be resolved.
A review of the Association's Rules and
Regulations, to accommodate the existence of the Library Management
Committee and new Service Level Agreement, is being undertaken and changes
should be in place in 2002. The arrangements for periodical exchanges with
other organisations are now being managed from Association headquarters
with the assistance of Mike Dampier from the University's Department of
Mathematics and Computer Science. Some past failings in distribution of The Mathematical Gazette have been redressed.
Mike Price
(Chair)
PRIMARY MATHS CHALLENGE
It really made the
children think but that's not a problem!
Primary Mathematics Challenge, in November 2001,
was taken by over 45000 pupils in 1175 schools (936 in England, 62 in
Scotland, 98 in Wales and 77 in Northern Ireland - 2 abroad). Over 31000
certificates were provided for presentation in these schools. In addition,
over 1000 pupils took the PMC Finals in February with 112 being awarded
medals for their excellent performance. There was overwhelming positive
comment. Some examples:
'A super challenge' :
'Good preparation for the maths challenges in secondary school' : 'The
challenge stimulated children to think creatively' : 'A wonderful variety
of questions' : 'The PMC has helped to boost confidence' : 'They loved
getting their certificates in assembly' : 'I really liked the follow-up
extension ideas' : 'Thank you for organising such a challenge'.
Thanks to a large grant from the Nuffield
Foundation, there will be a mailing to all primary schools in the UK this
year. The target for November 2002 is 2000 schools.
A book, giving the six PMC papers from November
1999 to February 2002, answers and notes, ideas for classroom extension
work and full lists of award winners is now available from the MA.
The success of the PMC is down to hard work by the
team members, Colin Abell, Robyn Pickles, Ruth Cullingworth and Trish
Morgan, with wonderful support from Marcia Murray and the staff at the MA
office. Thanks to all of them for their energy and talents!
We need more people on our two committees. Please
contact me if you are interested and want to find out what we do.
Peter
Bailey
PROBLEM BUREAU
Roger Wheeler has run the Bureau for 20 years and
must have clocked up something like 1800 solutions provided over those
years. It would appear that the number of solutions being requested
annually is now more like 30, but I feel that the Bureau still provides a
valuable service. I have stepped gingerly into Roger's shoes and trust
that I can continue his fine work.
Since taking over in August, I have received
requests from six people for 27 solutions. They have ranged from questions
directly relevant to the P1 syllabus at AS Level to a fierce question from
a Hungarian magazine. Fortunately, this latter one was eventually solved
by the enquirer!
Members of the Association are welcome to send in
any problems that can be thought of as pre-University and which are
troubling them, or for which they would like a second opinion. No promises
are made, but all will be looked at carefully, and hopefully,
sympathetically. Requests may be sent via Headquarters.
Graham
Howlett
HEADQUARTERS
We have seen yet another busy year at
Headquarters. The recent initiatives, e.g. marketing campaigns, Primary
Mathematics Challenge, increased exposure at exhibitions and conferences,
increased hands-on with our own Annual Conference and the professional
development initiatives, etc., etc., have all served to keep the hive
humming! The end of October 2001 saw the departure of Graham Richards,
who, after having thought long and hard, decided the time was right to
accept the Christian Missionary Fellowship's offer of increased work with
them. To replace Graham, Lisa Hall was employed and she started with the
MA at the beginning of December 2001. Lisa works full-time for the
Association and this means that we now have four full-time members of
staff and two part-timers. I hope members have benefited from the
increased 'human' contact time now available during the week. I am pleased
to report that a further four rooms have been decorated and that the
computers and software have been upgraded - we are now cooking with gas
and can hold our own - electronically speaking! There is still further
refurbishment to take place and most of this should be completed in the
coming year. I am hoping this next year is going to be just as busy for HQ
as the last; if we're busy it can only mean that the Association and its
activities are going from strength to strength as well.
Membership, including direct subscriptions, to
December 2001 is 5694.
At April 2002, the
Headquarters Team of Six is:– Office Manager -
Marcia Murray, Bookkeeper - Linda Medhurst, Membership Secretary - Sally
Bryan, Clerical Administrator - Lisa Marie Hall, Sales Administration -
Ann Goddard, Clerical Assistant - Anne-Marie Brown
Marcia Murray
(Office Manager)
RULES AND REGULATIONS
Herewith, notice of changes to the Regulations of
Branches, which were approved at the meeting of Council on 9 March 2002.
The new regulations can be viewed on webpage . Please contact Headquarters if
you require a hard copy of the page. [Phone 0116 221 0013 Fax 0116 212
2835]
REPORTS FROM REPRESENTATIVES ON OTHER
BODIES
Joint Mathematical Council
The Joint Mathematical Council (JMC) is the body
which brings together representatives of many mathematical organisations
within the UK. The list of all such bodies is too long to include but, as
well as the MA, there are representatives from the ATM, IMA and LMS as
well as advisers and other Associations. The geographical coverage is
good, with members from Wales and Scotland as well as England. As was
reported last year, the current Chair of JMC is Professor Celia Hoyles of
the London University Institute of Education and two prominent members of
the MA Council are also office bearers: Sue Sanders is the JMC secretary
and Adrian Oldknow its treasurer.
The JMC meets three times per year (November,
February, June) in the Royal Society. Meetings start late in the morning,
the main, routine business is intended to be fitted in before lunch with,
if possible, much of the afternoon being given over to a topic for
discussion. I attended all the meetings since April 2001 and I am
considerably more comfortable than I was when I first attended. It is
useful to know of other Associations and the work they do and to be able
to meet a wider range of individuals than usual.
Particular mention should be made of the Algebra
Working Group whose report was published and has been widely circulated.
In the last of these reports, I referred to the proposal to establish the
Advisory Committee on Mathematics Education (ACME). This has now been done
and its membership established. Sir Christopher Llewellyn Smith FRS, is
the chairman and the other five members are: Sue Sanders; Chris Robson;
Celia Hoyles; Chris Belsom and Annie Gammon. As its first priority, the
committee is addressing Continuing Professional Development. I will close
this report with the
ACME Mission
Statement
The Advisory Committee on Mathematics Education
(ACME) is an independent committee established by the Joint Mathematical
Council of the UK and the Royal Society, with the explicit support of all
major mathematics organisations. ACME is funded by the Gatsby Charitable
Foundation and acts as a single voice for the mathematical community,
seeking to improve the quality of mathematics education in schools and
colleges. Its role is to advise Government on issues such as the
curriculum, assessment and the supply and training of mathematics
teachers.
Bill Richardson (MA
representative)
The British Mathematical Olympiad
Committee
The International Olympiad in July 2001 was held
in Washington DC, USA, where the UK team of six gained 1 silver and 3
bronze medals, with an Honourable Mention for a fifth student. For the
2001-2002 cycle of tests, the first round of the BMO was brought forward
to December to avoid January exams, with the second round remaining in
February, followed by the usual training for twenty students at Easter,
hosted by Trinity College, Cambridge. In addition, the new UK Team Leader,
Geoff Smith, together with Deputy Leader Richard Atkins, held further
training camps for a squad of possible team members, at Bath in September
2001 and in Hungary in January 2002. This summer the UK hosts the IMO in
Glasgow.
Philip Coggins (MA
representative)
United Kingdom Mathematics Trust (UKMT)
The UKMT met five times during the Annual Report
period, with meetings in April, August, October January (2001) and March
(2002). Amongst its more usual activities the UKMT has been working on the
UK's hosting of the IMO in Glasgow this summer on the 24th and 25th July
(2002), with the whole programme extending from 18th to 30th July.
The Junior Challenge attracted 236600 entrants (a
16.5% increase). The top 900 were invited to take part in the Junior
Mathematical Olympiad. The Intermediate Challenge attracted 199930
entrants (a 17% increase), the top candidates were invited to take the
European Kangaroo, and/or the International Invitational Intermediate
Mathematics Competition as appropriate. The Senior Challenge attracted
53810 (a 7.8% increase), with the top 800 going on to BMO round 1, the top
100 of these went on to BMO round 2, and 20 were then selected for the
Trinity Training Session at Easter, a squad of eight is then selected for
further training and eventually the team of six which will represent the
UK in the IMO is selected.
Susie Jameson (MA
representative)
Organisation for Economic Co-operation &
Development / Programme for International Student Assessment
(OECD-PISA)
The first of the three, three-year cycles of the
programme was completed this year. The main focus was on literacy in the
mother tongue but literacy in science and mathematics was not ignored. The
fact that England came very high in the international league tables in
Mathematics and even higher in Science has received wide publicity with
consequent national or at least political celebrations. So much better
than the dreadful TIMSS results! In Germany, whose results were
disappointing, a spirit of national crisis prevails and deep questions are
being asked about the national education system etc.
The next three-year cycle will focus upon
mathematical literacy and we hope that this focus will generate rather
better questions than we saw in the first round. The next report is due in
2006 and I eagerly await the first batch of trial questiions!
Those seeking detailed results from the project
may find detailed reports on the following website www.statistics.gov.uk/releases.
Use the internal search engine to look up PISA.
The English report and exemplars of questions are amongst the items
available.
Roy Ashley (MA
Representative)
College of Teachers
The MA is an institutional member of this
organisation, which offers a professional body for teachers in the areas
not covered by Subject Associations and the Trade Unions. This means that
members of the MA can join for the discounted rate of £12 per year, soon
to increase to £15. Like the MA, they would like to attract as many
members as possible from the profession.
During the last year, the website has been, and
continues to be, considerably developed by Matthew Martin, a young teacher
who recently joined. This also provides links to many other educational
websites, including the Governmental ones.
The College of Teachers awards qualifications akin
to postgraduate degrees and diplomas, which incorporate experience,
insights and attendance on other courses. These can act as evidence for
new pay awards and performance management reviews.
The College of Teachers also publishes, free to
members, a regular newsletter and journal, Education Today. The recent edition contained
several articles on both 'Learning and Teaching', and 'Governance and
Management' from different countries. Articles appear which have a
general, not subject specific, interest to teachers, for example the
'Rationale for Performance Management, or School Leaders: born to be
made?' For more information, see the website at http://www.collegeofteachers.ac.uk or contact the
membership secretary, Mrs Valerie Early, College of Teachers, 33 John St,
LONDON, WC1N 2AT. Tel/fax 020 7404 2008. Email valerie@cot2.freeserve.co.uk
Tony Robin (MA
representative)
QCA Meeting with Subject Associations
The mathematics team at QCA has two meetings each
year with representatives of subject associations - AMET, NAMA, ATM and
The Mathematical Association. Six representatives from the MA, Sue
Sanders, Cathleen Brunt, Doug French, Trish Morgan, Robyn Pickles and
Charlie Stripp, have attended meetings this year. Topics discussed have
included: the implementation of the National Numeracy Strategy and the Key
Stage 3 National Strategy for Mathematics, where it has been useful having
Tim Coulson and Carole Macintyre, the respective directors, present at the
meetings; assessment issues, which are a recurrent theme of deep concern
to all the subject associations; and Post-16 developments, where we have
been well represented at other QCA meetings trying to sort out the
aftermath of Curriculum 2000.
Doug French (MA
representative)
European Federation of Associations of Mathematics
Teachers (EFAMT)
The MA has continued its involvement with the
European Federation of Associations of Mathematics Teachers (EFAMT), the
incipient umbrella body for mathematics teachers' organisations in the
EU.
There was a meeting in Paris on 30 June / 1 July
2001. I attended this meeting on behalf of the MA, and although this was
my third such attendance, it was in fact the first representing the MA as
an actual member of EFAMT. The meeting was again largely conducted in
French, although APMEP was now also represented by Catherine Dufosse, who
is happy to use both English and French. There is still a great deal of
enthusiasm for the project, especially from Jean-Paul Bardoulat and
Richard Cabassut of the French organisation APMEP, despite the again poor
attendance (only the MA, APMEP, FESPM (Spain), and SBPMef
(Belgium-francophone) were represented).
Much of this meeting was given over to the
devising of a questionnaire (in both languages) designed to gather
information about primary mathematics education in the various EU
countries. There was great enthusiasm for this, despite some doubts about
the methodological soundness of it. These doubts were acknowledged, but
pragmatism ruled. I was later involved in quite extensive work arriving at
an idiomatic translation of the questionnaire into English. Much
discussion was also given over to the legal status of the organisation,
and under which country's legal system it ought eventually to be properly
established.
During this meeting, the MA representative was
invited by APMEP as a guest to their annual meeting in Lille 29-31
October. In addition, two EFAMT meetings were arranged for 28 October in
Lille. One of these concerned the Primary Questionnaire. The response rate
had been very variable: Belgium 10, Germany 2, Spain 1, France 3, UK
(etc.) 0. Much time was spent collating responses from those round the
table (3 French, 1 Belgian, 1 Spanish, 1 UK). The meeting was conducted in
French. The other was a discussion in French of the project "Web Up Maths"
from CREEM (the French 'Centre for research and experimentation in the
teaching of mathematics'). The idea was to set this up under the MINERVA
initiative of SOCRATES.
The APMEP conference was an interesting experience
of a very different style of conference. There were 800 participants from
all over France and francophone Belgium. Long plenary lectures (in the
conference centre/concert hall in Lille) in the mornings (90 min),
including one by Nico Hirrt extolling the virtues of the free-market in
education and pointing to its successful use in UK. Afternoons were
workshops, a good 25-minute march away (in fine weather) in a local school
where participants could speak at length about their experience. One was
on teaching mathematics in English (now a French baccalaureate option) but
not a word of English was uttered! The exhibitions/displays were
interesting. The publishers/equipment exhibition had much emphasis on
calculators etc. There were some nice posters from students about the
calendar, golden ratio, history etc. and some nice 'manipulatives',
including a very large set of six 1 + 4 + 9 + 16 blocks for the sume of i2 – fun to
assemble as an n(n
+ 1)(2n + 1) cuboid (– and not so easy,
actually). Also there were exhibitions from local producers of
specialities such as cheese, waffles, beer etc. – a novelty for me:
perhaps the MA conferences could emulate this?
Neil Bibby (MA
representative)
Court of Loughborough University
The Vice Chancellor presented the Annual Report,
designed as a web document for the first time. Some highlights were:
- Loughborough had been successful for the third
time in receiving the Queen's Anniversary Prize for Higher and Further
Education (for Optical Engineering), a very rare achievement and never
bettered.
- The Duke of Edinburgh had opened Loughborough's
integrated Engineering Faculty buildings (a £14+ million investment with
major funding from the Wolfson Foundation).
- Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP had opened the Ford
Retail College on campus (a £10 million investment).
- Major ongoing sporting developments included
building an Olympic standard pool (a £7 million investment, due to open
July 2002), part of the English Institute of Sport Development
Programme.
- On research the University has done creditably
well in maintaining a strong research position at a time when many
universities were advancing forward quite significantly.
- One area of research to hit the news concerned
driver fatigue, investigated by Prof Jim Horne and colleagues of Human
Sciences. He had served as expert witness in a much-publicised trial
concerning a vehicle that ran onto a railway line resulting in a fatal
train crash.
- Loughborough continued to excel in the teaching
quality assessments with the University typically ranking in the top
five or better, including first equal in the Guardian league table.
- The students again excelled in raising funds
for local and national charities, achieving £167,000 in the year.
- In community action, some 500 student
volunteers worked on projects for the locality.
- Sporting achievements were outstanding, as
usual. The University men and women were again BUSA champions (for the
21st time and 23rd time respectively).
David Green (MA
representative)
LIST OF BODIES AND OUR REPRESENTATIVES
(n.b. Where formal representation is not invited
we have established informal links.)
|
Acronym
|
Body |
Committee |
Representative/Link |
Comments |
|
ACME |
Advisory Committee on Mathematics Education
|
Established jointly by Joint Mathematical
Council and Royal Society |
Dr S Sanders |
|
|
ASSET |
The Association of Science Engineering &
Technology |
Council |
None at present |
|
|
BATH |
University of Bath |
Court of the University |
Mr M Cornelius |
retiring |
|
CITS |
Department of Education and
Employment |
Curriculum IT Support Groups for Mathematics
|
Mr R Bridges |
|
|
COT |
College of Teachers |
Council |
Mr A C Robin |
|
|
EFAMT |
European Federation Association for
Mathematics Teachers |
|
Mr N Bibby |
|
|
IMA SFESA |
The Institute of Mathematics and its
Applications |
Schools and Further Education Service Area
|
Mr P Thomas |
informal link |
|
JMC |
Joint Mathematical Council |
Council |
Mr W P Richardson |
|
|
LOUGH |
University of Technology,
Loughborough |
Court of the University |
Dr D Green |
|
|
OCR |
Oxford, Cambridge and RSA
Examinations |
Mathematics Qualifications Panel |
Mr A Osbaldiston Mr
R Barbour |
currently dormant |
|
OECD-PISA |
Organisation for Economic Co-operation &
Development - Programme for International Student Assessment |
English steering group |
Mr R Ashley
Mr R Barbour |
|
|
PA |
Publisher's Association |
Teacher Pubilisher Liaison Committee |
To be announced |
|
|
QCA |
Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
|
National Curriculum Monitoring |
Mr S Abbott Ms C
Brunt Mr D French Ms
T Morgan Mrs R Pickles Dr S Sanders Mr C
Stripp |
|
|
SETNET |
Science Engineering Technology and
Mathematics Network |
|
Mr M Mudge |
Informal link |
|
UKMT |
United Kingdom Mathematics Trust |
Council |
Miss S Jameson |
|
| |
|
Senior Olympiad Subtrust |
Mr P J Coggins |
|
ACCOUNTS
REPORT OF THE COUNCIL : YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER
2001
Legal and administrative status
The Mathematical Association was founded in Great
Britain in 1871. The Association is registered as a charity under number
313281.
Constitution and objectives of the
Association
The objectives of the charity are to improve the
teaching of mathematics and its applications and to provide a means of
communication amongst students and teachers of mathematics for this
purpose, and to take such measures as may appear expedient to advance the
views of the charity on any question affecting the study and teaching of
mathematics and its applications. Such measures include the provision and
maintenance of the library, publication of periodicals and other items and
the holding of meetings and conferences.
Branches and Corresponding
Associations
With the approval of the Council, Branches of the
charity may be formed. The Council may also approve the designation of
other Associations as Branches, or as Corresponding Associations.
During the year there were 14 established branches
of the charity and 4 designated branches. The income and expenditure of
the established branches is included in these financial statements.
Trustees
The trustees who served during for part or all of
the year were:
Dr S. E. Sanders, Mr E. R. Ashley, Mr P. Metcalf,
Mr S. Abbott, Mr W. P. Richardson M.B.E., Miss S G Jameson, Mr P. Bailey,
Mr N. Bibby, Mr D. Carter, Ms P. M. Morgan, Mr M. Bailey, Prof. J. Berry,
Mr M. Mudge, Mr R. Barbour, Mr D. French, Mr D. Hodgson, Mrs R. Pickles,
Dr. W. Brakes, Mr M. Sanders, Mr C. Stripp, Prof. A. Oldknow, Dr. P.
Harris, Dr A Barnard, Ms A Gould, Mr Barry Lewis, Mr Michael Fox.
Members and officers
The charity consists of personal members,
including honorary members, and institutional members.
An elected Council monitors the business of the
Association. There are three Officers (Chair, Secretary and Treasurer),
elected annually (to each office) who are not allowed to hold office for
more than five years; there is a President, President Designate and
Immediate Past President, who each hold office for a period of one year;
seven Council members each act as the chair to a particular committee, who
may serve one term of four years within that office and there are nine
members without office, who may serve two terms of three years. The
Association's members, at the Annual General Meeting, elect all members of
Council, with the exception of the President, who is elected by
Council.
Risk Management
The trustees have examined the major strategic,
business and operational risks that the charity faces and confirm that
systems have been established to enable regular reports to be produced so
that necessary steps can be taken to lessen these risks.
Reserves Policy
It is the policy of the Association to maintain
sufficient general funds to cover management, administration and support
costs, and to enable it to respond to any further approved projects, which
arise from time to time.
Review of the financial statements for the
year
The charity achieved a surplus of £93,907 for the
year (2000 £43,722).
The charity is mindful of its responsibility to
improve the financial standing of the organisation and Council has already
put in place a rigorous policy towards the management of its resources and
finances, which is now beginning to reap benefits. The long-term future of
the charity depends upon its ability to maintain and strengthen its
membership base as well as ensuring that sufficient funding is secured to
support its various undertakings.
The Council has agreed the following transfers to
Designated Funds during the year:
- £10,000 to the Buildings Maintenance Fund for
the upkeep and maintenance of the headquarters' building.
- £23,250 to the Website Development Fund.
- £5,000 to the Life Membership Fund.
- £24,000 to the Conferences Fund.
- £5,000 to the IMO.
- £25,000 to the MA Development & Special
Projects Fund
Auditors
A resolution proposing the re-appointment of PKF
as auditors was proposed and agreed at the Annual General Meeting.
Principal address
The principal address of The Mathematical
Association is
259 London Road, Leicester LE2 3BE United
Kingdom.
By order of the Council
MR W. P. RICHARDSON M.B.E.
Chair of Council, 5 April 2002
STATEMENT OF COUNCIL'S
RESPONSIBILITIES
Law applicable to charities in England and Wales
requires the Council to prepare financial statements for each financial
year, which give a true and fair view of the financial activities of the
charity during the year and of its state of affairs at the end of the
year. In preparing those financial statements, the Council is required
to:
- select suitable accounting policies and then
apply them consistently;
- make judgements and estimates that are
reasonable and prudent;
- state whether applicable accounting standards
and statements of recommended practice have been followed, subject to
any departures disclosed and explained in the financial statements; and
- prepare the financial statements on the going
concern basis, unless it is inappropriate to presume that the Charity
will continue in operation.
The Council is responsible for keeping proper
accounting records which disclose with reasonable accuracy the financial
position of the charity and which enable them to ensure that the financial
statements comply with the applicable law. They are also responsible for
safeguarding the assets of the charity and hence for taking reasonable
steps for the prevention and detection of fraud and other
irregularities.
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE ACCOUNT: YEAR ENDED 31
DECEMBER 2001
| |
2001 |
2000 |
| |
£ |
£ |
|
INCOME |
|
|
|
Members' subscriptions |
228,589 |
199,155 |
|
Transfer from Life Membership Fund |
6,230 |
5,858 |
|
Donations |
18,557 |
1,036 |
|
Editorial board |
68,502 |
79,976 |
|
Publications |
| |