The X+Y Files

Issue 9

Betting to Win – the solution

The first thing to notice is that if the odds are 15 to 1 then a bet of, say £10, will give a profit of £150 if you win, i.e. you get your stake back, so it is better to think about “outlay £10, income £160”. We can draw up a table showing what will happen in the case of each horse winning:

Horse

odds

outlay

return if win

KNOW HOW

15 - 1

k

16k

EQUATION

11 - 1

e

12e

FIBONACCI

8 - 1

b

9b

FERMAT

7 - 1

f

8f

PASCAL

3 - 1

p

4p

NEWTON

2 - 1

n

3n

Total outlay, T = k + e + b + f + p + n

Now Mr H makes a profit of £120 whichever horse wins, so we have six equations:

 120 = 16kT = 12eT = 9bT = 8fT = 4pT = 3nT.

Dividing each of these equations we get a new set:

120

16

 = k –  

T

16

120

12

 = e – 

T

12

120

9

 = b –  

T

9

;   

120

8

 = f

T

8

;

120

4

 = p

T

4

120

3

 = n

T

3

If we add these equations together we get:

120

1

16

+

1

12

+

1

9

+

1

8

+

1

4

+

1

3

 = T – T

1

16

+

1

12

+

1

9

+

1

8

+

1

4

+

1

3

The fractions in the brackets add up to

139

144

 Thus  

120 × 139

144

 = T 1 –  

139

144

 =  

5

144

 ×

 T.

So T =

120 × 139

5

 = 3336.

With this value for T we can calculate the values of k, e, b etc.

This gives the amounts as:

KNOW HOW: £216,    EQUATION: £288,   FIBONACCI: £384,
FERMAT: £432, PASCAL: £864, NEWTON: £1152.

The key to all this is that bracket

1

16

+

1

12

+

+

1

3

.

 This is the 

sum of the reciprocals of 1 more than each of the odds. If this is less than 1 then it will always be possible to place the bets so that you can make a profit.

Unfortunately, the bookies know this!

Barry Humphreys